The Smith Island Sweet Shoppe, LLC
Famous Smith Island Layer Cakes
Smith Island Cake Bakery
Our specialty is Maryland's state dessert, a moist homemade cake with 10 ultra-thin, individually baked layers carefully stacked and frosted.
Smith Island cake is our family heritage
We were born and raised on Smith Island. My grand cousin, Frances Kitching, taught me to bake the 10-layer chocolate cake. We still bake them using our family's own tried-and-true cake recipe.
They're famous!
Most every Friday night my mother and my grandmother made a famous Smith Island layer cake. Now I'm baking them for you! I'm Cheryl Tull, and I invite you to try one of my famous Smith Island layer cakes.
Our Best Sellers Our Cake List
Chocolate Smith Island Cake - The one that started it all
Ten moist golden layers filled and covered with a rich cooked chocolate icing. Authentic and most popular. See more options
6-inch $25.00
9-inch $46.00
Our classic Red Velvet cake has ten moist red layers and luscious cream cheese frosting. See more options
6-inch $25.00
9-inch $46.00
Our moist yellow layer cake with creamy, rich vanilla and strawberry filling topped with fluffy vanilla frosting. See more options
6-inch $25.00
9-inch $46.00
Ten golden layers, thick sweet coconut filling, covered with rich cream cheese frosting and fluffy sweet coconut. See more options
6-inch $25.00
9-inch $46.00
Golden yellow cake layered with rich cream cheese frosting and sliced fresh bananas. See more options
6-inch $25.00
9-inch $46.00
Choc. Peanut Butter
Double Chocolate
Chocolate Banana
Banana Walnut
Banana Peanut Butter
Carrot Cake
Spice Cake
Pumpkin Spice
Red Velvet
Chocolate Red Velvet
Cookies 'N' Cream
Peaches 'N' Cream
German Chocolate
Boston Cream Pie Cake
All-butter Pound Cake
Devils Food
Death by Chocolate
Chocolate Walnut
Mounds Bar
Fudge Ripple
Peanut Butter Cup
Fresh Coconut
Coconut Pineapple
Shipping & Handling
Order your cake 3 or more days before you want to serve it. If you need a cake in a hurry, call us. We'll work with you to get it there as soon as possible. Your Smith Island cake is carefully placed in a sturdy insulated box with dry ice or frozen gel packs to keep it cool.
Warm Weather Shipping
To ensure quality product during the spring and summer months, online orders received after 12 noon on Thursday will get shipped the following Monday.
Our friends at the Sea Shell Café in Chincoteague believe that by combining the finest available natural and organic ingredients with classic culinary techniques, you will enjoy a healthy and memorable dining experience. They serve Smith Island Sweet Shoppe Smith Island cakes!
The U.S. Naval Academy has ordered 4,660 miniature cakes to be served to midshipmen during Army-Navy Spirit Week. The cakes ordered by the Naval Academy are tiny versions of the traditional 10-layer confections that became Maryland's official state dessert in 2008.
Home | Smith Island Cakes | Cookies | Biscuits | Candy | Crab Cakes | Contact Us
Copyright © 2014 The Smith Island Sweet Shoppe · Crisfield, Maryland 21817 · 443-614-2207
Bookmark and Share